After discussing the nature of relevance and its role in communication and cognition, it assesses two alternative ways of drawing the explicitimplicit distinction, compares relevance theorys approach to. Relevance theory the handbook of pragmatics wiley online. Relevance theory, like other broadly gricean approaches to pragmatics, takes as its starting. Cognitive resources can be allocated by comparing relevance of inputs. The present paper aims to analyse the translation of puns from a relevancetheory perspective. Raymond hickey pragmatics page 2 of 16 james and charles peirce and which is a precursor to linguistic pragmatics. This book probes into underresearched issues in l2 pragmatics. Previous efforts to link these fields have failed, but sperber and wilsons relevance theory rt, an approach to experimental pragmatics grounded in cognitive science, offers the bridge. School of oriental and african studies, 4 gower street, london wcie 6ha, uk received 20 february 1997.
The pragmatics is gricean, supplemented by austinsearle speech acts, and making use in a couple of places of ideas from relevance theory. Introduction relevance and cognition relevance and communication relevance and comprehension relevance theory and. Offers students an accessible introduction and an uptodate survey of the field, encompassing both established and new approaches to pragmatics addresses the. Theory, like most contemporary pragmatic theories, builds on two central features of the seminal work of h. Relevance theory is an alternative attempt to streamline and. A second difference rooted in the psychological conception of pragmatics is reliance on the representational theory of mind. Introduction relevance theory henceforth rt, a cognitive theory of human communication by d. Relevance theory and the communication of politeness. Firstly, pragmatic competence, pragmatic awareness and metapragmatic awareness are redefined and clearly distinguished on theoretical grounds. Translation relevance theory and the pragmatics of stephen. Relevance is the concept of one topic being connected to another topic in a way that makes it useful to consider the second topic when considering the first. Elsevier journal of pragmatics 30 1998 119 relevance theory and the communication of politeness mark jary english language unit. Most fundamentally, however, it is studied in epistemology the theory of knowledge.
A relevance theory perspective robyn carston ostensive communication, the paradigm case of which is verbal communication, is the domain of a dedicated cognitive system, according to relevance theory rt. Relevance theory henceforth rt is a cognitive pragmatics theory of human communication which was developed in the mid1980s by dan sperber and. The intention to inform the audience of ones informative intention. The importance of pragmatic communication by megan steiner. Relevance is a property of stimuli resulting from a positive balance between, on the one hand, the eventual interest that the stimulus might provide and, on the other hand, the mental effort required to process the stimulus. This paper summarizes aspects of relevance theory that are useful for exploring impairment of pragmatic comprehension in children. This paper 1 presents relevance theorys central commitments in detail and explains the theoretical motivations behind them. The concept of relevance is studied in many different fields, including cognitive sciences, logic, and library and information science. Relevance, pragmatics and interpretation by kate scott pdf and epub ebook 3. Grices william james lectures, delivered in 1967, offered the first systematic alternative to a code theory of communication and understanding. Outline of relevance theory deirdre wilson, dan sperber department of linguistics university college london cnrs and crea ecole polytechnique, paris abstract in this paper, we outline a relevancebased approach to pragmatics, the theory of utterance interpretation. The point of the early concentration on semantics is to encourage readers to grapple with semantics before they have seen pragmatics as a.
Full text of paper available at in this chapter, i bridge rhetoric and pragmatics, both of which concern. The tenets of relevance theory are couched in talk of processing representations, rather than, and sometimes in addition to, the ordinary terminology of philosophical psychology. Relevance theory is seen to provide a means of explaining why, in a given context, a particular utterance is problematic. According to such theoretical framework, the relation between a translation and its source text is considered to be based on interpretive resemblance, rather.
The aim is to explain in cognitively realistic terms what these expectations amount to, and and how they might contribute to an empirically plausible. Relevance theory is based on a definition of relevance and two principles of relevance. Over the past twenty years, relevance theory has become a key area of study within semantics and pragmatics. This paper outlines the main assumptions of relevance theory while attempting to clear up some common objections and misconceptions and points out some new directions for research. The author adopts a resolutely cognitive approach to pragmatics and, using concepts and notions from relevance theory, sheds new light on the ways in which l2 pragmatic competence might be fostered. In this chapter, i bridge rhetoric and pragmatics, both of which concern themselves with languageinuse and meaningmaking beyond formal syntax and semantics. In the relevancetheoretic rt framework, within which carstons work on pragmatics is set, explicit communication concerns those propositions that are communicatively intended by the speaker and are derived by the hearer through a combination of linguistic decoding and pragmatic inference. Introduction relevance and cognition relevance and communication relevance and comprehension relevance theory and mental architecture conclusion. Relevance theory is broadly gricean in assuming that general pragmatic principles guide interpretations and that the principles involved are broadly rational. A brief sketch of some important terms the application of relevance theory rt to the translation of. Relevance theory is a cognitioncentered pragmatic approach to human communication which is based on the hypothesis of a single evolved mental capacity of human beings. Dec 04, 2018 in this chapter, i bridge rhetoric and pragmatics, both of which concern themselves with languageinuse and meaningmaking beyond formal syntax and semantics.
Relevance theory is a framework for understanding utterance interpretation first proposed by dan sperber and deirdre wilson and used within cognitive linguistics and pragmatics. The tenets of relevance theory are couched in talk of processing representations, rather than, and sometimes in addition to, the ordinary terminology of. We sketch an inferential account of unencoded causal and temporal components of utterance. In this paper, we outline a relevancebased approach to pragmatics, the theory of utterance interpretation. Relevance theory is a framework for the study of cognition, proposed primarily in order to provide a psychologically realistic account of communication. There are typical themes which one finds treated in discussions of pragmatics. Relevance theory is a cognitivelyoriented pragmatic theory that aims at providing a psychologically realistic account of utterance interpretation.
As such, it is a breath of fresh air in the literature in. Introduction to pragmatics guides students through traditional and new approaches in the field, focusing particularly on phenomena at the elusive semanticspragmatics boundary to explore the role of context in linguistic communication. After discussing the nature of relevance and its role in communication and cognition, it assesses two alternative ways of drawing the explicitimplicit distinction, compares relevance theorys approach to lexical pragmatics with those of grice and neogriceans, and discusses the rationale for relevance theorys conceptualprocedural. Grice 1 to develop a pragmatic theory which is at once philosophically sensitive and empirically plausible in both psychological and evolutionary terms. The comprehensive theoretical and methodological treatment of pragmatic competence makes this book of interest to researchers and students in pragmatics, l2 theory and applications, genre studies, and to those concerned with the cognitive underpinnings of communication in l2. Pdf bridging rhetoric and pragmatics with relevance theory. Pragmatics theory of human communication and cognition 2. Pdf bridging rhetoric and pragmatics with relevance. Ling 236, stanford potts conversational implicature. Paul grice and developed out of his ideas, but has since become a pragmatic framework in its own right. It argues that the hearer readeraudience will search for meaning in any given communication situation and having found meaning that fits their. Relevance theory is a cognitivepragmatic approach to communication proposed by sperber and wilson in the mid1980s sperber and wilson, 1986. Relevance theory over the past twenty years, relevance theory has become a key area of study within semantics and pragmatics. Ss saying that p conversationally implicates q iff i.
Relevance theorys influence mainly falls within the area of linguistic pragmatics, which focuses on how people understand each other when they communicate verbally clark, 20, p. These are dealt with in the following parts of the present section. Relevance theory and the pragmatics of translation stephen pattemore introduction. Pdf relevance theory through pragmatic theories of meaning. It explores data from three children with pragmatic language diffi culties within this framework. A brief sketch of some important terms the application of relevance theory rt to the translation of the bible has proved surprisingly controversial. Recommend this book email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this book to your organisations collection. Problems raised by the application of relevance theory relevance theory.
Feb 28, 20 the cognitive principle of relevance the communicative principle of relevance relevance theory does not provide an absolute measure of mental effort or cognitive effect and does not assume such a measure is available to spontaneous workings of the mind. The cognitive principle of relevance the communicative principle of relevance relevance theory does not provide an absolute measure of mental effort or cognitive effect and does not assume such a measure is available to spontaneous workings of the mind. We argue, contrary to most received opinion, that cognitive linguistics and relevance theory provide complementary perspectives on metaphor. The relevance theory relevance theory is a proposal by dan sperber and deirdre wilson. Relevance theory through pragmatic theories of meaning ahtiveikko pietarinen ahtiveikko. Relevance theory cambridge textbooks in linguistics. We sketch an inferential account of unencoded causal and temporal components of utterance interpretation as in. Outline of relevance theory deirdre wilson, dan sperber department of linguistics university college london cnrs and crea ecole polytechnique, paris abstract in this paper, we outline a relevance based approach to pragmatics, the theory of utterance interpretation. Studies of linguistic politeness have traditionally assumed a gricean normbased approach to communication. Relevance theory and pragmatic impairment leinonen. The main aim of a pragmatic theory is to explain how. Focal areas in relevance theory and discourse analysis relevance theory focuses on the relationship between meaning and context, both textexternal and textinternal context the latter is sometimes called cotext. For wilson 2000, grice pioneered the belief in utterance interpretation as a variety of inferential mindreading, derived from a general metapsychological humanevolved ability to recognise intentions behind actions. Considerations on cognitive effort as a criterion for markedness in pragmatics.
Focusing on the implicit aspects of communication, grice argued that the implicatures of an utterance are not decoded but inferred, by a nondemonstrative. Relevance theory is based on a definition of relevance and two principles of. In the fields of pragmatics and semantics among others, relevance theory is the principle that the communication process involves not only encoding, transfer, and decoding of messages, but also numerous other elements, including inference and context. Focusing on the implicit aspects of communication, grice argued that the implicatures of an utterance are not decoded but inferred, by a nondemonstrative inference process in which contextual assumptions and. As such, it is a breath of fresh air in the literature in this area and deserves to be very widely read. Relevance theory is a cognitively oriented theory of pragmatics, i. Relevance theory, a cognitive pragmatics theory of human communication, was developed in the mid1980s by dan sperber and deirdre wilson in their book, relevance. S is presumed to be observing the maxims, or at least in the case of. Cognitive linguistics and relevance theory markus tendahla, raymond w.
On this view, instances of the use of polite forms andor strategies necessarily communicate a message above and beyond the one that motivates the communicative act. Bridging rhetoric and pragmatics with relevance theory by. Pdf relevance theory is a framework for the study of cognition, proposed. Relevance theory s influence mainly falls within the area of linguistic pragmatics, which focuses on how people understand each other when they communicate verbally clark, 20, p. In this comprehensive new textbook, billy clark introduces the key elements of the theory and how they interconnect. The present paper aims to analyse the translation of puns from a relevance theory perspective. Pdf pragmatics is a branch of linguistics that investigates the ways language is tied to the contexts in which it is used. Relevance theory and generalized conversational implicatures 48 anglogermanica. Dan sperber, who developed relevance theory together with deirdre wilson.
784 362 120 185 919 1410 875 13 1359 118 776 1180 487 690 959 180 750 743 423 228 330 348 1036 238 590 430 658 1004 1304 1418 1203 123 113 1360 373 320 615 801 595 39 1337 1034 916 539 1218 1353 166